Whereas HBO’s Home of the Dragon is exploring the historical past of the household that ruined Westeros for practically 300 years, many followers have been clamoring for the story of one other ruling household from Sport of Thrones. In any case, the Kings within the North dominated for millennia as proud and simply rulers who did proper for his or her kingdom and need to have their tales advised.
In fact, the Starks misplaced their crown when the Targaryens arrived and have been solely capable of reclaim it when Robb Stark rose up towards the ruling King Joffrey and proclaimed himself King within the North as soon as extra. But whereas most followers love Robb Stark, there are some with some fairly unpopular opinions of the late younger king.
An Boastful King
Robb was a younger lord raised up as king by his males, who proclaimed that the North needs to be impartial once more. Some followers assume it made him smug. “He dismissed the recommendation of his bannermen who have been attempting to advise him on the right way to win the battle, which Robb continued to disregard,” says Redditor MDE427, “and, as his victories piled up, he grew overconfident that he was in the proper on all of it.”
In fact, Robb wasn’t fully smug. Late within the battle, he knew he was near dropping, which is why he tried to appease Lord Frey as greatest as he may. He additionally typically tried to hearken to his mom and tended to have glorious command over battles, to the purpose the place he hardly wanted recommendation on the right way to win them. So, whereas he was barely smug, it wasn’t misplaced.
The Finest King
There have been many kings in Sport of Thrones, and Robb was actually one of many least evil kings. But, provided that Jon Snow later turned King within the North, most followers agree that Jon was the very best ruler of all, as he knew when to kneel for his individuals. But Redditor lulugothica says, “Robb is a greater King than Jon.”
On condition that Jon sacrificed his kingdom for the survival of the human race, it is arduous to argue that Robb was higher, given the last word destiny of his bannermen. All Jon ever cared about was preventing the lifeless, and he achieved his one purpose. Robb, who meant to free the North, could not, which actually makes Jon a greater ruler.
Robb was a noble lord who led the North into battle to free after which to avenge his father. But, after the supposed deaths of Bran and Rickon, Robb made some fairly dumb selections and even broke his vow to marry Talisa. Redditor colourfulsevens says that, for Talisa, “Robb condemned hundreds of younger boys to demise.”
It is a honest critique, although one Robb actually could not have predicted. Whereas he knew he would offend Walder Frey, nobody anticipated the unprecedented brutality of the Crimson Wedding ceremony. Robb ought to have saved his vows, but it surely’s arduous guilty all these deaths on certainly one of Frey’s many victims.
In fact, Walder Frey wasn’t the one one to betray Robb. Roose Bolton was one other traitor, and he was reviled by nearly all of the North for his actions through the Crimson Wedding ceremony. But Redditor E-Nezzer says, “I do not assume Roose Bolton betrayed Robb Stark for his personal egocentric ambition. I imagine he did it to avoid wasting his nation from a protracted battle being fought in two fronts that was already misplaced.”
In fact, that is giving Roose an excessive amount of credit score. He was the most effective secondary villains within the present, because of his utter lack of look after Theon, Robb, and even Jaime Lannister. He allowed Ramsay free rein over the North, which triggered indescribable destruction. So it’s kind of far-fetched to imagine he was doing all of it with noble objectives and did not betray Robb out of his personal ambition.
Too A lot Like Ned
The son of one of the honorable characters in Sport of Thrones, Robb had so much to dwell as much as and evidently failed. “Robb could be very self-aware of emulating his father and attempting to behave as his father would (and messes it up, frankly),” says Reddit person CheruthCutestory. “It isn’t probably the most pure factor for him.”
Robb was at all times attempting to maintain his males loyal by appearing like his father, and it will definitely led to an arrow within the again and a knife to the chest. Nonetheless, he tried to maintain from dishonoring Talisa, whereas proving he was a fierce and simply king by killing Lord Karstark. He actually was like Ned, and it is a part of why he died.
Many followers imagine Robb’s main poor resolution was marrying Talisa, however some go additional. “The Starks bought precisely what they deserved for his or her constant behavior of constructing horrible selections – Robb particularly,” says Redditor SanshaXII, who argues Robb can be alive, “If he hadn’t betrayed Walder Frey – which he completely, unarguably did.”
In fact, all of the poor selections on this planet should not have damned Robb to a destiny just like the Crimson Wedding ceremony. Frey broke visitor proper, slaughtered a complete military, and desecrated Robb’s physique. Robb could have slighted Walder, however he actually did not deserve the implications he acquired.
The younger King within the North was a reasonably normal protagonist in a fantasy sequence, which is why Reddit person CrayonFox describes Robb as “simply the lamest character in your complete present.” In fact, viewing him as lame or boring is ignoring a few of the deeper components of the character.
Robb’s desperation to juggle ten thousand males, a complete battle technique, and hostages being slaughtered beneath him is a genuinely fascinating story. His love affair with Talisa was participating, as have been the political video games he performed afterward to right his errors. He could have been noble, however like Ned, that does not imply he is boring.
Too Judgemental Of Edmure
The lord of the most effective homes in Sport of Thrones, some followers assume Edmure Tully deserved greater than insults and amusing monitor from the council. “Edmure was extraordinarily competent for somebody solely so quick in energy, however bought bashed by his nephew as a result of Cat nonetheless thinks her brother is silly,” says Reddit person Arninator.
Edmure took initiative and tried to assert a mill for Robb when Robb refused to share the complete particulars of his plans together with his bannerman. Had Robb merely defined the scenario, Edmure would have adopted orders and captured the Mountain. As a substitute, Robb blamed Edmure for his personal miscommunication and compelled the person to marry a Frey to make up for a perceived slight.
But Robb can also be judged by the fanbase greater than he deserves. “He was brutally punished for the meagre variety of the errors he made,” says Redditor Rylingo. “Underneath totally different circumstances he would have gained the battle and retained the north.”
Had Walder Frey not damaged visitor proper in an unprecedented trend, Robb would have been capable of go house, reclaim Winterfell, and Bran and Rickon can be secure. As a substitute, he is judged for one thing he by no means may have predicted, and he actually deserved higher.
His Youth Is Important
Whereas most followers view Robb as a discovered king, he wasn’t actually skilled sufficient to steer. “He is principally a 16-year-old boy attempting to rule a kingdom, lead a military, dwell as much as his father’s legacy, safe the discharge of his sisters, and doing all of it towards probably the most ruthless calculators within the seven kingdoms,” says a now-deleted Reddit person.
His youth and inexperience clarify a lot of his struggles all through the battle. He was a superb army mastermind, however he did not have the affect to steer a military or take care of his bannermen. Had he had extra years of coaching beneath his father, he may need succeeded. As a substitute, he was thrust into battle too early, and the outcome was as predictable because it was tragic.
Subsequent: 10 Unpopular Opinions About The Last Season Of Sport Of Thrones, In accordance To Reddit